MRG Rogue Software Test
#1
Malware Research Group is presenting our latest Unofficial test, Rogue Software test.

Methodology used in this test:
1.Windows XP Professional Service Pack 3 is installed and updated with all important updates.
2. An image of the Operating System is created.
3. A clone of the Imaged system is made for each program to be used in the test.
4. An individual program is installed on each of the Cloned systems.
5. On each Cloned system the package containing 60 samples of Rogue Software is placed.
6. All the programs are fully updated.
7. Real Time protection/On Access scanners as well as all other methods of detection/prevention used by various Security Applications are turned on prior to the start of the test.
8. The test is conducted by trying to install each of the 60 Rogue Software samples.
9. In this test goal is to block the installation of each of the 60 Rogue Software samples, therefore we allowed various categories of Security Applications to be used in the same test, we tested mostly Antivirus, Anti-Malware and Internet Security Suite applications with their default settings (out of the box).
10. After each program, used in this test, is tested on all 60 Rogue Software samples, the system is being checked for any traces of the Rogue Software samples and malware (as many samples are packed with malware and malicious codes).
11. We will show the list of missed Rogue Software samples for each of the programs which failed to block all 60 Rogue Software samples.
12. The results will be presented separately for Antivirus/Anti-Malware and Internet Security Suite applications.

We have used the following Rogue Software applications in this test:
Antispyware Protector 2009
Antivirus Doctor
Computer Defender 2009
Error Wiz
PC Security 2009
Malware Cleaner
Home Antispyware 2010
Security Mechanic
Optimizer Easy
Windows Antivirus Pro
PC Doc Pro
PC On Point
Perfect Defender 2009
Perfect Optimizer
Registry Fix Program
Adware Spyware Remover
Registry Repair
Advanced Audio CD Burner
Advanced Audio DJ Mixer
Advanced Audio CD Ripper
Advanced Video Editing
Advanced Audio Extractor
Clean N'' Optimize
Audio Converter Extractor Mix
Software Depo DVD Player
Software Depo DVD Ripper
FTP and Download helper
Software Depo FLV Player
Advanced Icon Editor
Software Depo iPodManager
Advanced Image Viewer
Advanced MP3-WAV Converter
Free Internet Speedd Up Lite
Advanced Net Speed Up
Advanced DVD Rip and Burn
SWD Spy Message
Advanced System TuneUp
Video Converter Max
Advanced Video Editor
MySpace.com Video Grabber
Video Cutter Max
System Security
Security Mechanic
Reg Genie
Reg Tool
Antivirus Pro
Windows Security Suite
Advanced Virus Remover
Error Fix
Antisoyware 2009
Spyware STOP
SPYware REMOVER
Malware Removal Bot
Adware Alert
Registry Smart
Antispyware Bot
Smart Protector
Macro Virus
XP Deluxe Protector


The results of our testing for Antivirus/Anti-Malware applications:

a-squared Anti MalwareSuccessfully blocked all Rogue Software samples used in this test.

Ad-Aware Free Anniversary Edition Failed to block the following Rogue Software samples:
Antispyware Protector 2009, Antivirus Doctor, Computer Defender 2009, Error Wiz, Optimizer Easy, PC Doc Pro, PC On Point, Perfect Optimizer, Registry Fix Program, Adware Spyware Remover, Registry Repair, Advanced Audio DJ Mixer, Security Mechanic, Reg Genie, Reg Tool, Error Fix, Antisoyware 2009, Spyware STOP, SPYware REMOVER, Malware Removal Bot, Adware Alert, Antispyware Bot, Macro Virus.


avast! Professional EditionFailed to block the following Rogue Software samples:
Computer Defender 2009, Error Wiz, Optimizer Easy, Windows Antivirus Pro, PC Doc Pro, PC On Point, Perfect Optimizer, Registry Fix Program, Adware Spyware Remover, Registry Repair, Advanced Audio CD Burner, Advanced Audio DJ Mixer, Advanced Audio CD Ripper,Advanced Video Editing, Advanced Audio Extractor, Clean N'' Optimize, Audio Converter Extractor Mix, Software Depo DVD Player, Software Depo DVD Ripper, FTP and Download helper,Software Depo FLV Player, Advanced Icon Editor, Software Depo iPodManager, Advanced Image Viewer, Advanced MP3-WAV Converter, Free Internet Speedd Up Lite, Advanced Net Speed Up, Advanced DVD Rip and Burn, SWD Spy Message, Advanced System TuneUp, Video Converter Max, Advanced Video Editor, MySpace.com Video Grabber, Video Cutter Max, Reg Genie, Reg Tool, Antivirus Pro, Windows Security Suite, Error Fix, Antispyware 2009, Adware Alert, Spyware STOP, SPYware REMOVER, Malware Removal Bot, Registry Smart, Antispyware Bot, Macro Virus.

AVG Anti-Virus ProfessionalFailed to block the following Rogue Software samples:
Antivirus Doctor, Computer Defender 2009, Error Wiz, Optimizer Easy, PC Doc Pro, PC On Point, Perfect Optimizer, Registry Fix Program, Adware Spyware Remover, Registry Repair, Advanced Audio CD Burner, Advanced Audio DJ Mixer, Advanced Audio CD Ripper,Advanced Video Editing, Advanced Audio Extractor, Clean N'' Optimize, Audio Converter Extractor Mix, Software Depo DVD Player, Software Depo DVD Ripper, FTP and Download helper,Software Depo FLV Player, Advanced Icon Editor, Software Depo iPodManager, Advanced Image Viewer, Advanced MP3-WAV Converter, Free Internet Speedd Up Lite, Advanced Net Speed Up, Advanced DVD Rip and Burn, SWD Spy Message, Advanced System TuneUp, Video Converter Max, Advanced Video Editor, MySpace.com Video Grabber, Video Cutter Max, Reg Genie, Reg Tool, Windows Security Suite, Error Fix, Antispyware 2009, Adware Alert, Spyware STOP, SPYware REMOVER, Malware Removal Bot, Registry Smart, Antispyware Bot, Smart Protector, XP Deluxe Protector.

Avira AntiVir PremiumFailed to block the following Rogue Software samples:
Computer Defender 2009, Error Wiz, Optimizer Easy, PC Doc Pro, PC On Point, Advanced Audio DJ Mixer, FTP and Download helper, Reg Genie, Reg Tool, Error Fix, Registry Smart, Antispyware Bot, Macro Virus.

Dr.Web for WindowsFailed to block the following Rogue Software samples:
Antispyware Protector 2009, Computer Defender 2009, Error Wiz, Malware Cleaner, Optimizer Easy, PC Doc Pro, PC On Point, Perfect Optimizer, Registry Fix Program, Adware Spyware Remover, Registry Repair, Advanced Audio DJ Mixer, FTP and Download helper, Reg Genie, Reg Tool, Error Fix, Antispyware 2009, Adware Alert, Spyware Stop, SPYware REMOVER, Malware Removal Bot, Registry Smart, Antispyware Bot, Smart Protector, Macro Virus, XP Deluxe Protector.

G DATA AntivirusFailed to block the following Rogue Software samples:
Computer Defender 2009, PC Doc Pro, PC On Point, Registry Fix Program, Adware Spyware Remover, Registry Repair, Advanced Audio DJ Mixer, FTP and Download helper, Antivirus Pro, Antispyware 2009.

Kaspersky Anti-VirusFailed to block the following Rogue Software samples:
Computer Defender 2009, Error Wiz, Optimizer Easy, PC Doc Pro, PC On Point, Perfect Optimizer, Advanced Audio DJ Mixer, FTP and Download helper, Reg Genie, Reg Tool, Error Fix, Antispyware 2009, Spyware Stop, SPYware REMOVER, Registrty Smart, Antispyware Bot, Macro Virus.

Malwarebytes'' Anti-MalwareFailed to block the following Rogue Software samples:
Computer Defender 2009, Error Wiz, PC Doc Pro, PC On Point, Advanced Audio DJ Mixer, FTP and Download helper, Reg Genie.

Microsoft Security Essentials (Beta)Failed to block the following Rogue Software samples:
Error Wiz, PC Doc Pro, PC on Point, Registry Fix Program, Adware Spyware Remover, Registry Repair, Advanced Audio CD Burner, Advanced Audio DJ Mixer, Advanced Audio CD Ripper, Advanced Video Editing, Advanced Audio Extractor, Clean N'' Optimize, Audio Converter Extractor Mix, Software Depo DVD Player, Software Depo DVD Ripper, FTP and Download helper, Software Depo FLV Player, Advanced Icon Editor, Software Depo iPodManager, Advanced Image Viewer, Advanced MP3-WAV Converter, Free Internet Speedd Up Lite, Advanced Net Speed Up, Advanced DVD Rip and Burn, SWD Spy Message, Advanced System TuneUp, Video Converter Max, Advanced Video Editor, MySpace.com Video Grabber, Video Cutter Max, Reg Genie, Reg Tool, Error Fix, Antisoyware 2009, Spyware STOP, SPYware REMOVER, Malware Removal Bot, Adware Alert, Registry Smart, Antispyware Bot, Macro Virus.


Norton AntivirusFailed to block the following Rogue Software samples:
Antispyware Protector 2009, Error Wiz, Optimizer Easy, Windows Antivirus Pro, PC Doc Pro, PC On Point, Perfect Optimizer, Registry Fix Program, Adware Spyware Remover, Registry Repair, Advanced Audio CD Burner, Advanced Audio DJ Mixer, Advanced Audio CD Ripper,Advanced Video Editing, Advanced Audio Extractor, Clean N'' Optimize, Audio Converter Extractor Mix, Software Depo DVD Player, Software Depo DVD Ripper, FTP and Download helper,Software Depo FLV Player, Advanced Icon Editor, Software Depo iPodManager, Advanced Image Viewer, Advanced MP3-WAV Converter, Free Internet Speedd Up Lite, Advanced Net Speed Up, Advanced DVD Rip and Burn, SWD Spy Message, Advanced System TuneUp, Video Converter Max, Advanced Video Editor, MySpace.com Video Grabber, Video Cutter Max, Reg Genie, Reg Tool, Error Fix, Antispyware 2009, Spyware Stop, SPYware REMOVER, Registry Smart, Macro Virus.

Nod32Failed to block the following Rogue Software samples:
Error Wiz, Optimizer Easy, Windows Antivirus Pro, PC Doc Pro, PC On Point, Perfect Optimizer, Registry Fix Program, Adware Spyware Remover, Registry Repair, Advanced Audio DJ Mixer, FTP and Download helper, Reg Genie, Reg Tool, Antivirus Pro, Error Fix, Spyware Stop, SPYware REMOVER, Malware Removal Bot, Smart Protector.

Panda Cloud AntivirusFailed to block the following Rogue Software samples:
Antivirus Doctor, Computer Defender 2009, Malware Cleaner, Security Mechanic, Optimizer Easy, Windows Antivirus Pro, PC Doc Pro, PC On Point, Registry Fix Program, Adware Spyware Remover, Registry Repair, Reg Genie, Reg Tool, Antivirus Pro, Error Fix, Antisoyware 2009, SPYware REMOVER, Registry Smart.

Prevx 3Successfully blocked all Rogue Software samples used in this test.

Spy EmergencyFailed to block the following Rogue Software samples:
Antispyware Protector 2009, Error Wiz, Optimizer Easy, PC Doc Pro, PC On Point, Registry Fix Program, Adware Spyware Remover, Registry Repair, Advanced Audio CD Burner, Advanced Audio DJ Mixer, Advanced Audio CD Ripper, Advanced Video Editing, Advanced Audio Extractor, Clean N'' Optimize, Audio Converter Extractor Mix, Software Depo DVD Player, Software Depo DVD Ripper, FTP and Download helper, Software Depo FLV Player, Advanced Icon Editor, Software Depo iPodManager, Advanced Image Viewer, Advanced MP3-WAV Converter, Advanced Net Speed Up, Advanced DVD Rip and Burn, SWD Spy Message, Video Converter Max, Advanced Video Editor, MySpace.com Video Grabber, Video Cutter Max, Security Mechanic, Reg Genie.

VIPRE Antivirus+AntispywareFailed to block the following Rogue Software samples:
Reg Tool, Error Fix.


The results of our testing for Internet Security Suites:

COMODO Internet Security (All Features Enabled) Failed to block the following Rogue Software samples:
PC On Point, Advanced Audio DJ Mixer, FTP and Download helper.

Online Armor ++ (All Features Enabled) Failed to block the following Rogue Software samples:
Reg Genie

Outpost Security Suite (All Features Enabled) Failed to block the following Rogue Software samples:
Antivirus Doctor, Computer Defender 2009, Error Wiz, Optimizer Easy, PC Doc Pro, PC On Point, Perfect Optimizer, Registry Fix Program, Adware Spyware Remover, Registry Repair, Advanced Audio DJ Mixer, Reg Genie, Reg Tool, Antivirus Pro, Error Fix, Antispyware 2009, Adware Alert, Spyware Stop, SPYware REMOVER, Malware Removal Bot, Registry Smart, Antispyware Bot, Smart Protector, Macro Virus.

Panda Internet Security (All Features Enabled)Failed to block the following Rogue Software samples:
Computer Defender 2009. Error Wiz, Optimizer Easy, PC Doc Pro, PC On Point, Reg Genie, Reg Tool, Error Fix, SPYware REMOVER.

źródło:

[Aby zobaczyć linki, zarejestruj się tutaj]


No no nie spodziewałem się takiego wyniku Pandy IS. Avast, AVG, Norton i Morro żal.pl Nic tylko pogratulować a-squared, Comodo IS i OASmile
Odpowiedz
#2
czyli na czerwono nie wykryte?Online Armor ++ i Comodo naprawdę dobrze sobie ostatnio radzą w testach
Odpowiedz
#3
Zgadza się Smile
Odpowiedz
#4
tak raczej
Odpowiedz
#5
Ten test to jedna wielka bzdura. Autorzy testu sa powiazani z firma Comodo, poza tym na forum udostepniali duze ilosci probek bioracych udzial w tym tescie.

Totalny brak profesjonalizu i obiektywizmu. Omijac takie testy szerokim lukiem.
Creer,
Member of the Alliance of Security Analysis Professionals
Odpowiedz
#6
Vipre zadziwiająco dobrze
Odpowiedz
#7
przecież pisałem że OA ++ będzie czarnym koniem w tym a roku
WIN11
Ventura
Odpowiedz
#8
Avira, G Data kasper, nodnie miala takich plecowWink
Odpowiedz
#9
Creer napisał(a):Ten test to jedna wielka bzdura. Autorzy testu sa powiazani z firma Comodo, poza tym na forum udostepniali duze ilosci probek bioracych udzial w tym tescie.

Totalny brak profesjonalizu i obiektywizmu. Omijac takie testy szerokim lukiem.


no to lipa ten test a już sie cieszyłem z wyniku OA
LikwidatoR napisał(a):Avira, G Data kasper, nodnie miala takich plecowWink


avira nie wypadła źle w porównaniu np do kasperskiego
WIN11
Ventura
Odpowiedz
#10
Dozamet1 napisał(a):Vipre zadziwiająco dobrze


vipre to mistrz fp Smile
Nie ważne jak mocno uderzasz, ale jak mocny cios potrafisz przyjąć od życia i iść dalej. Ile możesz znieść i ciągle iść na przód! Tak się wygrywa. Użalanie się nad sobą nie przynosi rozwiązań.... !
Odpowiedz
#11
no to wiem że fp ma masę.No to lipa a nie test szkoda
Odpowiedz
#12
avira nie wykryla 13 sampli , kasper 16Wink
Odpowiedz
#13
Norton coś cieniutko.. A tak jechali po darmowych programach.Grin
Odpowiedz


Skocz do:


Użytkownicy przeglądający ten wątek: 1 gości